Off-Page SEO: Building Authority in a Skeptical World

Backlinks are votes of confidence. When other sites link to yours, Google interprets that as third-party validation that your store is trustworthy. The more quality sites that link to you, the more authority Google assigns. Authority influences rankings.

This is also the hardest part of SEO. You can’t directly create backlinks the way you can write descriptions or fix title tags. You have to earn them. That takes time, and there are no shortcuts that don’t eventually backfire.

What AI Changed

Google’s AI Overviews tend to cite authoritative sources. Stores with established trust signals are more likely to be referenced in these summaries. If Google doesn’t trust your site, you’re not getting cited, and you’re probably not getting clicks either.

Authority also provides stability during algorithm updates. When Google makes changes, sites with strong backlink profiles and established reputations tend to experience less volatility. In uncertain times, authority is insurance.

The AI era didn’t make backlinks less important. It made trust more important, and backlinks remain how Google measures trust.

What Matters

Quality over quantity: One link from a respected industry site beats 50 links from random directories.

Relevance: Links from sites in your niche carry more weight than links from unrelated sites.

Diversity: Natural link profiles show variety. All your links coming from one source looks suspicious.

Brand mentions: Google can recognize mentions of your brand even without links. They count for something.

Reviews: Google Business Profile reviews and third-party review sites signal trust.

What to Do

1. Check What You Already Have

Use Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (free) or Moz Link Explorer to see who links to you now. Look at the quality. Are these legitimate sites or spam directories? Understanding your current profile helps you know what to build on.

2. Claim Your Google Business Profile

Even for primarily online stores, this establishes legitimacy. It enables reviews visible in search and creates a branded knowledge panel. Fill out every field, add photos, respond to reviews. It’s a trust signal Google explicitly controls.

3. Get Listed Where It Matters

Skip the generic directories. Look for legitimate industry-specific resources. A fabric store might target quilting guild directories and sewing community lists. A jewelry store might seek craft marketplace features. Quality listings in places your actual customers browse.

4. Create Something Worth Linking To

People link to useful resources. A sizing guide that becomes the go-to reference. A comparison tool that saves people time. Original research about your niche. Content that provides genuine value attracts links naturally over time.

5. Build Relationships, Not Just Links

Partner with complementary brands that share your audience but don’t compete directly. A fabric store might collaborate with a sewing machine retailer. These relationships can produce natural cross-promotion and links that last.

6. Make Reviews Easy

Happy customers don’t automatically leave reviews. You have to ask. Follow up after purchases with direct links to your Google Business Profile or relevant review platforms. Respond to every review, positive or negative. Engagement signals trust.

7. Monitor Your Profile

Set up Google Alerts for your brand name. Periodically check your backlink profile for new spam links you didn’t request. If you accumulate toxic links from dubious sources, you may need to disavow them before they become a problem.

Tools

Backlink Analysis: Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (free), Moz Link Explorer, Ahrefs or SEMrush (paid)

Monitoring: Google Alerts (brand mentions), Mention.com

Outreach: Hunter.io (find emails), BuzzStream (manage campaigns)

How This Connects to Survival

Authority and engagement work together. When visitors arrive from a trusted referring site, they’re often more qualified. They came through a recommendation, not a random search. Better visitors engage better.

And building authority requires having something worth linking to. Stores where visitors bounce immediately don’t earn recommendations. Good engagement makes authority building possible. Authority amplifies the benefits of engagement.

This takes time. Start now, and the effects compound. Wait, and you’re always playing catch-up.

Get the Full Checklist

It has all the action items in one place. Download the complete Shopify SEO Survival Checklist.

Download The Shopify SEO Survival Checklist

Haven’t taken the quiz? Find out where your store stands: The Shopify SEO Survival Quiz (2 minutes).

Woodcut illustration of Balloon handing out information. Banner reads Off-Page

Learn more how AI affects SEO

Engagement — Google now tracks how visitors behave on your site. This is the factor most stores ignore and the one that separates survivors from casualties.

Analytics — You can’t fix what you can’t see. This is how you know whether you’re winning or losing the engagement game.

Technical SEO — If your site is slow or broken on mobile, engagement dies before it starts. This is the foundation everything else sits on.

Content — Google’s AI now evaluates your entire site, not just individual pages. Thin content anywhere drags everything down.

Keywords — Informational searches now go to AI Overviews. You need to target what still gets clicks.

On-Page SEO — With 61% fewer clicks available, your titles and descriptions have to work harder.

Off-Page SEO — Authority signals provide stability during algorithm changes, but this is the slowest lever to move.